Thursday, March 10, 2011

Group Unit Thoughts

      When we were introduced to the idea of a group unit, I was skeptical and wondering how it would all work out.  I like working on a project in groups because we can bounce ideas off each other and get different ideas that we may not have thought about individually. The thing that bothers me is how we must show who did what for every part of the lesson.  A lot of our ideas were collaboratively generated during our group’s discussions, who gets the credit for those ideas? According to Google docs, it is the person who typed them.  But in reality we all deserve the credit.  I find that this way of evaluating who did what will push us to work more individually rather than collaboratively because we will be trying to stake claim to original ideas.  Maybe a more effective way of evaluating participation would be to have us individually evaluate our group members at the end of the semester on criteria such as 1. Contribution, 2. Willingness to help, 3) Communication with group members ect…
At first, I was not sure how it would work being placed in a group with Science or Spanish content areas.  But this cross-disciplinary lesson planning with a Spanish content area on the topic of US/Cuba relations has been working great.   We have not had to do anything like this in our other classes as we have always been placed within our content areas.  I like being challenged to think
across disciplines because this is becoming increasingly more prevalent in today’s schools.
One idea I have to involve the community in the classroom would occur in lesson three.  Within this lesson is the topic of the Cuban Missile Crisis.  Students will interview a relative about their experiences during this time.  Such questions could include “What did you think when you first heard Kennedy’s speech about nuclear missiles being deployed in Cuba?” “What was life like during these thirteen days of uncertainty when the country was at the brink of nuclear war, what were your feelings?” “What were your opinions about the decisions the US made?”  “How do you remember the media covering this event?”  Students will share their completed interviews with their classmates. This will gives students a sense of what it was like living during this historical period.  It will help them
relate to this event knowing that their relatives experienced it.

7 comments:

  1. I like the idea of getting interviews with relatives that lived thourgh. It was one of the most real threats of nuclear war on U.S. soil

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that most of us had the same skeptical feelings you describe here. I know that I did and I've been reading a lot of other blogs that seem to say the same thing! However, like you, once you start working on everything you see that it is easier than anticipated. I thought it was interesting that your group also thought that by interviewing members of the community the students could greatly benefit! Our group had the same idea! Our unit is on immigration and we thought it might be a great idea for students to find members of the community that are immigrants and to learn a little bit from them which they will bring back to class and share with other students! Great ideas!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel like you guys lucked out having someone who's a future spanish teacher in your group. i think that would bring a great deal to the group especially with a topic on cuba and us relations. I like your idea about interviewing a relative about their experience. It will give them a better understanding of the event but also feel connected knowing their family members lived through it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I do agree with you in reference to the grading of the project and who thought of what and who typed what in google docs. It seems as if the only way that we will be graded and know that each individual group member has participated equally is if we all typed at the same time and that is seriously confusing and somewhat ridiculous.

    I did have the same reservations as you did in reference to cross-discipline work, but unfortunately for me, things are not working out as smoothly as they are for you. It is very hard to think about three very different disciplines and try to culminate them and make a lesson plan about them in reference to fairy tales.

    I think your interview idea is great.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Have you thought about connecting it to any of the issues of today and the threats that have happened in the last 10-15 years?
    Is there a way to get a perspective from Cuba?
    I am open to other ways of evaluating that you think would be fair. Your idea of having the group evaluate could work for some groups. We can talk about it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really like your idea ;) interview is the best thing to get information about something and also it can be enjoyable for the students.
    And, I agree with you that how we must show who did what for every part of the lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with some of the troubles you have experienced during the lesson planning process. Personally, I think part of our problem is that we still haven't had enough time to work out the kinks in the system. But, I'm also starting to realize that there is something to be said for good old fashion human communication. As it stands, I feel like our group could have gotten everything done faster if we would have actually sat down together to make collaborative decisions. I've noticed a lot of times decisions have been delayed because we are waiting for approval from others; but sometimes it takes a day in order to hear back from them.

    ReplyDelete